Our History

Paragon Subrogation Services, Inc., a privately held California corporation, was founded in 1995 with a goal of providing quality multi-line subrogation and arbitration outsourcing services to self-insured entities and insurance carriers. Paragon offers superior value, outstanding service, and impressive net recoveries while eliminating the costs associated with in-house subrogation.

• 1995 Ani Naccachian, a pioneer in the outsourced subrogation industry, founds Paragon Subrogation Services to provide uninsured motorist and arbitration services to leading insurers.

• 1997 Paragon recovers the first $1 million for our clients.

• 1997 Paragon audit results achieve 100 percent accuracy on client audits.

• 1998 Paragon is one of the first outsourced companies to join The National Association of Subrogation Professionals.

• 1999 Paragon recovers $10 million for our clients.

• 2001 Paragon expands services to include litigation files.

• 2002 Paragon doubles our office space to account for business growth.

• 2003 Paragon receives our 5-year certification from the National Association of Subrogation Professionals (NASP). Paragon becomes the only company allowed to advertise as “E-Speed Specialists.”

• 2003 Paragon files more than 14,000 arbitration files on behalf of our clients.

• 2003 Paragon becomes the largest filer of third-party arbitration claims with Arbitration Forums. Paragon ranks third in the total industry, behind State Farm and Allstate.

• 2003 All Paragon arbitration specialists are named Arbitration Forums panelists.

• 2004 Paragon implements a system allowing our clients real-time access to their files, 24 hours a day.

• 2004 Paragon recovers more than $20 million for our clients.

• 2005 Selected by Arbitration Forums to beta-test the latest version of high-speed online arbitration filing system, generating significant time savings and improving cash flow for clients.

• 2005 Paragon Subrogation Services celebrates its tenth year in business. 

• 2006 Paragon launches our MedPay division with an industry-leading insurance carrier.

• 2008 Paragon enhances our online, real-time client portal to allow clients to both read and place notes within individual files.

• 2009 Paragon enhances our reporting system to enable clients to run online statistical analyses of files placed with us.

• 2010 Paragon Subrogation Services celebrates 15 years of business, continuing to be the nationwide leader in the subrogation industry.

• 2013 Paragon Subrogation Services upgrades to new state of the art web based client access system.

• 2014 Paragon Subrogation Services receives Woman Owned Business Certification from WBENC, the industry standard for third-party certification.

• 2015 Paragon Subrogation Services celebrates its twentieth year in business. 

• 2016 Paragon increases office space to keep up with business growth.

• 2017​ Increased our staff by 30% to meet our growth needs.

• 2021​ Acquired by Fleet Response, a specialized auto TPA offering comprehensive claims management solutions, including claims, maintenance, and safety management programs for companies or organizations with large auto exposure.